Steam trap monitoring

ABSTRACT

Electronic steam trap monitoring is disclosed. An electronic steam trap monitor is operably coupled to an outlet of a steam trap and is configured to measure at least one process variable of fluid (liquid or gas) flowing through the trap, when the trap is known to be working normally. The steam trap monitor stores the process variable information obtained during the known operating condition for later comparison. The steam trap monitor obtains a later process variable measurement and compares it to the stored measurement to selectively generate a leakage indication. The steam trap monitor preferably uses a local power source and communicates wirelessly.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

The present invention is related to the monitoring of steam traps. More particularly, the present invention is related to a system and method for detecting a leak in a steam trap.

Steam traps are commonly used in many industries to remove unwanted air and condensate from steam lines. In a typical plant, thousands of such devices may be deployed. A steam trap is generally a relatively low technology device that is designed to be relatively inexpensive. Often, steam traps are completely mechanical. Adding any electrical wiring for either power or monitoring would be considered cost prohibitive, impractical and/or labor intensive.

A steam trap is generally designed to allow condensate to escape a pipe in order to maintain efficiency and reduce pipe “knocking.” A typical steam trap may have one or more chambers and a member that is in physical contact with the condensate. As the level of the condensate rises above some threshold, the movable member within the steam trap actuates, or otherwise engages one or more valves to allow the condensate to escape. As the condensate escapes, the level of condensate within the steam trap is reduced to such an extent that the valve is closed and the trap re-pressurizes.

Steam traps experience a very common problem; they often leak. Steam trap leakage is often due to wear of the movable member within the steam trap, deterioration or fouling of the valve (s), or a number of other reasons. Regardless of the cause, steam trap leakage is undesirable for a number of reasons. First, it takes a relatively large amount of energy to heat water into steam. Thus, a leaking steam trap will allow steam to escape before the energy content therein can be fully utilized. Further, many condensate removal systems are not designed for continuous pressurization, such as that caused by a steam leak. Accordingly, the component(s) downstream from a steam trap could be damaged, or otherwise degraded, by a continuous steam leak. Finally, given a sufficient leak, the steam pipe may not be able to supply sufficient steam pressure and flow to achieve its desired purpose.

Accordingly, it is believed that users of steam traps would desire the ability to determine if one or more of their steam traps were leaking. Currently, methods used to monitor steam traps require providing cable runs to the steam trap, or rely on non-electrical approaches.

SUMMARY

Electronic steam trap monitoring is disclosed. An electronic steam trap monitor is operably coupled to an outlet of a steam trap and is configured to measure at least one process variable of fluid (liquid or gas) flowing through the trap, when the trap is known to be working normally. The steam trap monitor stores the process variable information obtained during the known operating condition for later comparison. The steam trap monitor obtains a later process variable measurement and compares it to the stored measurement to selectively generate a leakage indication. The steam trap monitor preferably uses a local power source and communicates wirelessly.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a diagrammatic view of a steam trap with which embodiments of the present invention are useful.

FIG. 2 is a diagrammatic view of another steam trap with which embodiments of the present invention are useful.

FIG. 3A is a diagrammatic view of a steam trap monitoring system coupled to a steam trap in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 3B is a perspective view of a portion of steam trap monitor in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 3C is a cutaway perspective view of a potion of the steam trap monitor shown in FIG. 3B.

FIG. 4 is a block diagram of electronics within a steam trap monitor in accordance with embodiments of the present invention.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE ILLUSTRATIVE EMBODIMENT

Embodiments of the present invention can be practiced with respect to any steam trap that has an inlet that is coupled, or couplable, to a steam pipe, and an outlet that periodically releases condensate and/or air, but otherwise is expected to maintain an elevated pressure with respect to the ambient environment.

FIG. 1 is a diagrammatic view of a steam trap with which embodiments of the present invention are useful. Steam trap 100 is fluidically coupled to steam pipe 102 and water collection/return line 104. Steam pipe 102 has steam disposed therein at first pressure (P1) and first temperature (T1). The steam may be static or flowing, and may be saturated steam or superheated steam. Condensate flowing, or otherwise present within steam pipe 102 will flow into inlet 106 and accumulate in the chamber 108. Chamber 108 includes an outlet port 110 that is closed or occluded by movable member 112. Movable member 112 may comprise a baffle or any other suitable physical structure. As condensate 114 accumulates within chamber 108, the level 116 of condensate 114 rises. As the level rises, the amount of condensate displaced by movable member 112 increases thereby increasing the degree to which the buoyancy of member 112 urges member 112 upward. At some point, the level of condensate 114 will reach a threshold where movable member 112 lifts into the position indicated in phantom at reference numeral 118. Once member 112 lifts, condensate 114 drains through outlet 110 for a short period of time. Once sufficient condensate 114 has drained, gravity will bring member 112 down into contact with outlet 110 thereby sealing outlet 110. In this manner, steam trap 100 will periodically release quantities of condensate 114 and some air and steam. During these intervals while condensate is being released, a temperature (T3) and a pressure (P3) will be relatively higher than when member 112 seals outlet 110.

FIG. 2 is a diagrammatic view of another steam trap with which embodiments of the present invention are useful. Steam trap 200 is coupled to steam pipe 102 and return line 104. Trap 200 includes trap body 202 that is coupled to, or includes, inlet 204 that is fluidically coupled to steam pipe 102. Accordingly, condensate, or other liquids, flowing or otherwise present within steam pipe 102 will descend conduit 206 and enter trap body 202 via inlet 204. Fluid 208 thus accumulates within trap body 202. Float 210 is disposed within trap body 202 and is configured to float upon a selected amount of fluid 208. As float 210 rises, it will eventually come into contact with movable member 212 of valve 214. When float 210 moves member 212 sufficiently, valve 214 will open thereby coupling upstream portion 216 to downstream portion 218. Upstream portion 216 is fluidically coupled to location 220 proximate the bottom of trap body 202. Accordingly, fluid 208 proximate location 220 will flow into conduit 222; through valve 214; through conduit 224 and into return line 104. The flow of fluid 208 is facilitated by the relatively higher pressure within steam line 102, which pressure (P) bears against surface 226 of fluid 208.

The temperature of inlet 204 is illustrated as T1, while the temperature proximate outlet 228 is illustrated as T2. The temperature of condensate within return line 104 is at T3.

In order to allow embodiments of the present invention to be practiced with existing, or legacy, mechanical steam traps, it is preferred that no modifications need to be made to such devices. Thus, embodiments of the present invention are generally directed to providing steam trap monitoring for any steam trap that has an inlet and an outlet that periodically releases condensate without necessitating any modification to the steam trap itself, or requiring any wiring to be run to the steam trap.

FIG. 3A is a diagrammatic view of a steam trap monitoring system coupled to a steam trap in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention. For simplicity, the steam trap illustrated in FIG. 3A is steam trap 200 described with respect to FIG. 2. However, any steam trap may be used, as set forth above. Steam trap monitor 230 is coupled to outlet 228 of steam trap 200. For the sake of illustration, assume 300# saturated steam is provided within steam pipe 102. At this pressure the steam temperature is approximately 412° F. Accordingly, the temperature within steam trap 200 will also be approximately 412° F. T3, in contrast, will be approximately the temperature of saturated steam at atmospheric pressure, or 212° F. Steam traps are generally insulated in order to minimize thermal energy lost to the environment. As illustrated in FIG. 3A, T2 is the gas temperature located just downstream of outlet 228 of steam trap 200. In accordance with embodiments of the present invention, steam trap monitor 230 includes one or more process variable sensors in order to detect one or more steam characteristics proximate outlet 228.

During normal steam trap operation, saturated steam and condensate are both present in trap body 202. This will cause the temperature of trap body 202 to be approximately temperature T1. The steam trap monitor, if mounted directly to steam trap body 202, will also have its casing at approximately the same temperature as body 202, which will again be about equal to T1. If no steam or condensate is flowing out of steam trap 200, the gas temperature, T2, will be about equal to T3 or, for an atmospheric pressure scavenging system, about 212° F. In practice, T2 may be a few degrees higher due to radiation heat transfer from steam trap body 202 and the case of steam trap monitor 230. In at least one embodiment of the present invention, T2 is measured by using a temperature sensor disposed within monitor 230. A reference T2 measurement can be obtained and stored during known non-leaking operation. Then, later measurements can be compared with the reference measurement for steam trap leakage diagnostics.

The temperature descriptions given above are generally true when no steam or condensate is flowing out of trap 200. However, if trap 200 has collected sufficient condensate, buoyant forces lift float 210 and open valve 214. This allows condensate to flow through outlet 228 until the buoyant forces are insufficient to lift float 210. Typically, some saturated steam may also escape during this process, depending on the details of the design of steam trap 200. During the discharge period, the condensate and steam will heat a temperature sensor within steam trap monitor 230 to approximately the temperature of T1 (nearly 412° F.). After the discharge period has ended, the temperature of the sensor within steam trap monitor 230 will gradually return to T2 along a classic first order system decay curve.

In the case of a leaking steam trap, the reading from the sensor (S2) that measures T2 will consistently remain close to that of the saturated steam leaking through the valve. The larger the leak, the better T2 will match the T1 temperature. Preferably, embodiments of the present invention also include a second process variable sensor (preferably a second temperature sensor) that is disposed to measure temperature T1, or the temperature of the casing of steam trap monitor 230 which is thermally coupled to steam trap body 202. Preferably, electronics within steam trap monitor 230 will store readings related to the T1 and T2 temperatures. Over time, an average temperature difference can be determined and stored relative to the T1 and T2 temperatures, excluding the period(s) that the steam trap condensate valve is open. Detecting that the valve is open can be determined by noting a rapid T2 temperature change that results in T2 being approximately equal to T1. Certainly, other techniques and methods can be used to sense the flow of condensate or pressurized fluid through steam trap monitor 230.

Due to the relatively large amount of energy available to purge condensate, steam trap condensate valves are usually only open for brief periods, typically less than one minute. If the temperature (T1) indicated by the sensor proximate the casing of steam trap monitor 230 is nearly equal T2 for long periods of time (such as exceeding 10 minutes) or if the average difference between the readings between the two sensors during periods when the valve should be closed gets below a predetermined threshold, steam trap monitor 230 can provide a leakage indication.

The actual form of the leakage indication can be any suitable annunciation or message transmission. Examples include very inexpensive annunciations, such as providing a local color change at the housing of steam trap monitor 230. The annunciation can also be more sophisticated, such as providing a FOUNDATION™ Fieldbus or HART® compatible alarm wirelessly. Further, the alarm can also be an audible alarm. While a preferred embodiment contemplates providing a wireless alarm, it is appreciated that the process variable sensor may be wired, such as to a two-wire process control loop to both power the sensor and communicate an alarm.

FIG. 3B is a perspective view of a portion of steam trap monitor 230 in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention. Monitor 230 includes casing 232 that includes a surface 234 that is adapted to couple to steam trap body 202 or steam trap outlet 228 in a manner that thermally couples monitor casing 232 to steam trap body 202. Preferably, steam trap monitor 230 employs a plurality of temperature sensors. As illustrated in FIG. 3B, steam trap monitor 230 preferably includes casing temperature sensor 236 disposed to sense a temperature of casing 232. The type of temperature sensor used for temperature sensor 236 can be any suitable device capable of generating, or otherwise providing, an electrical characteristic in response to a temperature. Examples of suitable temperature sensors include thermocouples, thermistors, and resistance temperature devices (RTDs). In one embodiment, temperature sensor 236 is a thermocouple. Steam trap monitor 230 also preferably includes a second temperature sensor 238 that is thermally isolated from casing 232 and disposed to measure a temperature of gas within casing 232.

FIG. 3C is a cutaway perspective view illustrating the positioning of temperature sensor 238 in greater detail. As set forth above with respect to temperature sensor 236, temperature sensor 238 can be any suitable device, but is preferably a thermocouple. Further, in a preferred embodiment, casing 232 is a field hardened, plastic enclosure that is substantially waterproof and adapted for exposure to climatological extremes. Further, the temperature measurements do not necessarily require high accuracy, so electronics employing inexpensive, simple microcontroller(s) with an on-chip analog-to-digital converter can be used. However, many other suitable electrical arrangements can be employed for the circuitry of steam trap monitor 230. Such circuitry will be described with respect to FIG. 4.

Annunciation of a steam trap leak is preferably accomplished using a solid black LCD that is integral with housing 232, which LCD preferably changes color, such as to red, if an alarm condition exists. While the descriptions of FIGS. 3B and 3C have illustrated an embodiment employing two temperature sensors, embodiments employing more than two temperature sensors are also practicable. For example, in other embodiments, it may be useful to also measure T3. This is particularly so for cases where the steam is superheated (not saturated) and where its temperature varies over time, or when the water scavenging system pressure varies a great deal. This scavenging pressure variation will cause the saturation temperature to vary. By measuring all of temperatures T1, T2 and T3 independently, the same technical approach described above can be employed to determine if the steam trap is leaking. Such situations can be addressed using only two temperature measurements, but the lag in the S1 measurement of T1 (as T1 changes) should be accounted for in the software algorithm doing the diagnostic assessment. One favorable aspect about superheated steam systems is that the temperature differences between T1 and T3 are generally much larger than in saturated systems. This higher temperature difference allows the leak detection technology to be much more sensitive to small leaks.

Steam traps are also used to eject trapped air. Any air ejected by the trap will have been in intimate contact with the steam at temperature T1, so it will be at a similar temperature. Sensor 238, measuring S2, will respond to the air as if it were saturated steam, except that the air will decompress as it passes through the valve. This decompression reduces the air's instantaneous temperature. For the worst-case scenario, the air exiting may be cool enough so that the leak detector would not detect that the valve had opened. This would not detract from steam trap monitor 230's leak detection function, which generally relies upon sensing the increased temperature of leaked steam, if present, by sensor 238. In actual service, air ejection normally only occurs at start up, or restart up. Under normal conditions, condensate or steam are the only ejected fluids or gasses.

While much of the description thus far has focused upon the sensing of multiple temperatures throughout the steam trap process, sensing different or additional process variables, such as pressure, can also be employed. For example, at each of the locations illustrated by T1, T2 and T3 in FIG. 3A, pressure can also be measured. For example, referring back to FIG. 1, there are three pressures and temperatures illustrated. When movable member 112 closes, the P2 and T2 measurements should be roughly the same as P1 and T1, which are the pressure and temperature of the steam in steam pipe 102. However, when trap 100 opens, the pressure and temperature will be similar to the pressure and temperature in collection/return line 104. By measuring these variables, embodiments of the present invention advantageously “characterize” the behavior of the steam trap when it is new and in good working order. However, as the steam trap ages and develops a leak, the behavior of the trap will be different. If there is a leak, then P2 and T2 will behave significantly differently. Rather than becoming nearly equal to the steam pipe pressures and temperatures, P2 and T2 would be slightly lower. Additionally, instead of being nearly equal to the pressure and temperature (P3, T3) in return line 104, P2 and T2 will be slightly higher. The degree to which these relationships occur will generally depend on the nature and degree of the leak. However, by measuring P1, T1, P2, T2 and P3, T3 it is believed that embodiments of the present invention can compare the current state of the trap (which may be leaking) to a characterized state (such as when it was commissioned or determined to be in good working order). This comparison then allows a technician or controller to determine whether the steam trap is leaking, and even the degree to which it is leaking.

FIG. 4 is a block diagram of electronics within a steam trap monitor in accordance with embodiments of the present invention. Steam trap monitor 230 generally includes a local source 300 of power. Local power source 300 is generally able to provide all required electrical power to the rest of circuitry within steam trap monitor 230 without requiring any wired connections to the external environment. Examples of power module 300 can include an internal battery, as well as, or in addition to, devices that are adapted to generate electricity. Such devices include wind generators, solar cells, circuitry that generates electricity from vibration, and thermal generators. In a preferred embodiment, module 300 includes thermal generator 302 that generates electricity from heat flow. Known examples of thermal generator 302 include thermocouples and devices that employ the Peltier effect. Accordingly, one side 304 of generator 302 is coupled to a source of high temperature, such as steam pipe 102. While another side 306 of thermal generator 302 is coupled to a relatively lower temperature, such as the ambient environment. In accordance with known concepts, the presence of a temperature differential across sides 304 and 306 of thermal generator 302 will generate electricity that is supplied to power converter circuit 308. Circuit 308 can include any combination of suitable circuitry to condition, amplify, or otherwise adapt the electricity provided by generator 302 into a more suitable form. Additionally, voltage regulator 310 can be employed and coupled to power conversion circuit 308 to provide a stable voltage for the circuitry of steam trap monitor 230. Although no connecting lines are illustrated tying module 300, or voltage regulator 310 to additional components within steam trap monitor circuitry, such notation is provided for clarity. In fact, the output of power module 300 is actually coupled to all circuits within the steam trap monitors that require electricity.

Power module 300, in some embodiments, is able to operate even when steady state energy conversion levels do not meet the needs of steady state power consumption. For example, power module 300 may cause the monitor to go into a low-power state wherein electrical energy consumption is curtailed significantly while energy is stored. Then, periodically the monitor can be powered up, check for a leak, generate an indication, if appropriate, and return to its low-power state. Additionally, the monitor can receive a wireless, or local operator, command to enter a low-power mode. In this manner, effective steam trap monitor operation can be effected using relatively little steady state energy. While a preferred embodiment illustrates the use of a local source of power 300, an alternative embodiment allows for connection to a wired source, such as a two-wire process control loop to both power the steam trap monitor and provide communication to and from the monitor.

The steam trap monitor circuitry also preferably includes a clock 312 generating a clock signal that is provided to power transformer drive circuit 314 and microprocessor and/or signal conditioning module 316. The provision of a clock signal helps maintain synchronicity among the circuitry of steam trap monitor 230. Microprocessor/signal conditioning circuitry 316 can be any circuitry that is adapted to execute code to provide functions within steam trap monitor 230. Microprocessor/signal conditioning module 316 is coupled to wireless communications module 318 through data bus 320.

Wireless communications module 318 receives data from circuitry 316 and generates appropriate wireless communication signals based thereon. Additionally, wireless module 318 can receive wireless communications and provide data relative to the wireless communications to microprocessor/signal conditioning circuitry 316 through data bus 320. Examples of wireless communication module 318 include any technology now known or later developed that is able to provide or transmit information without wires. Wireless communication 318 can communicate process-related information as well as device-related information. Depending upon the application, wireless communication module 318 may be adapted to communicate in accordance with any suitable wireless communication protocol including, but not limited to: wireless networking technologies (such as IEEE 802.11b wireless access points and wireless networking devices built by Linksys of Irvine, Calif.), cellular or digital networking technologies (such as Microburst® by Aeris Communications Inc. of San Jose, Calif.), ultra wide band, free space optics, Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM), General Packet Radio Service (GPRS), Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA), spread spectrum technology, infrared communications techniques, SMS (Short Messaging Service/text messaging), or any other suitable wireless technology. Further, known data collision technology can be employed such that multiple units can coexist within wireless operating rage of one another. Such collision prevention can include using a number of different radio-frequency channels and/or spread spectrum techniques.

Monitor 230 can push steam trap leakage indication(s) to one or more designated receivers of such information periodically, or upon the occurrence of an event such as a determination of steam trap leakage. This leakage indication can be an indication of non-leakage, leakage, both, or any other suitable indication. Additionally, monitor 230 can also provide such information upon request. This request may come in the form of a wireless command received via module 318, or via a local operator interface (not shown). The request may be directed to a single monitor address, or to a group of monitors within wireless range. Additionally, the request could be generated periodically, such that each monitor is periodically polled for leakage information.

Power module 300, power transformer drive circuit 314, clock generating circuit 312, microprocessor/signal conditioning 316, and wireless module 318 are preferably electrically isolated from the measurement circuitry of monitor 230. This isolation is preferably in the form of transformer isolation, but may take any suitable form. Clock recovery circuit 324 is coupled to power transformer 322 and is adapted to provide a clock signal 326 that is preferably identical to that of clock generating circuit 312. Additionally, power transformer recovery circuit 328 is also coupled to power transformer 322 and generates electricity for measurement circuits from energy provided by power transformer 322. While power transformer recovery circuit is illustrated as not being coupled to additional components, such notation is provided for clarity. In fact, power transformer recovery circuit 328 is operably coupled to all measurement circuits that require electricity.

As set forth above, embodiments of the present invention preferably employ a plurality of process variable sensors to detect steam leaks. FIG. 4 illustrates circuitry of steam trap monitor 230 employing a plurality of measurement modules 330, 332, 334 and 336. Each module is configured to generate a digital indication of a process variable by interacting with a process variable sensor. Some modules can be configured to interact with a plurality of process variable sensors as well as other measurement modules. For example, module 334 is able to obtain pressure measurement P2 and temperature measurement T2, as well as communicate with module 336 over bus 340. Measurement modules 330, 332, 334 and 336 can be any circuit able to generate digital process variable information by interacting with process variable sensors. Thus, an analog-to-digital converter could be considered a measurement module. Further, an entire Application Specific Integrated Circuit (ASIC) with one or more analog-to-digital converters, a multiplexer, and additional circuitry for linearization or compensation could also be considered a measurement module. Preferably, modules 334 and 336 are ASICs with an internal capacitance-to-digital converter. Additionally, it is preferred that module 330 include a capacitance-to-digital converter, while module 332 have a voltage-to-digital converter. However, other combinations can be employed in accordance with embodiments of the present invention.

Although the present invention has been described with reference to preferred embodiments, workers skilled in the art will recognize that changes may be made in form and detail without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. 

1. An electronic steam trap monitor comprising: a power storage device configured to power the electronic steam trap monitor; an electrical generator coupled to the power storage device; a first temperature sensor disposed to measure a first temperature of a fluid released from the stream trap; a second temperature sensor configured to measure an external temperature of the steam trap; first measurement circuitry coupled to the first and second temperature sensors to provide a first representation of the temperature of the fluid released from the trap and an external temperature of the steam trap; signal processing circuitry operably coupled to the measurement circuitry to receive the first representation of the process variable; and wherein the signal processing circuitry is configured to store reference information relative to the first representation obtained during known non-leaking operation, and wherein the signal processing circuitry compares subsequently obtained temperature information with the reference information to selectively generate a steam trap leakage indication; and wherein the electronic steam trap monitor is mounted proximate an outlet of the steam trap.
 2. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, and further comprising a casing, housing the power storage device, the first temperature sensor, the measurement circuitry and the signal processing circuitry, wherein the casing is thermally coupleable to the steam trap, but wherein the first temperature sensor is thermally isolated from the casing.
 3. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, wherein the power storage device is a battery.
 4. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, wherein the generator is a solar generator.
 5. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, wherein the generator is a thermal generator.
 6. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 5, wherein the thermal generator is coupled to a steam pipe.
 7. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, wherein a reference temperature difference, obtained during non-leaking operation, between the first and second temperature sensors is stored, and wherein the signal processing circuitry is configured to compare a later temperature difference with the reference temperature difference to generate the leakage indication.
 8. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, and further comprising an LCD display coupled to the steam trap monitor, and wherein the leakage indication is provided by the LCD display.
 9. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, wherein the signal processing circuitry is communicatively coupled to the first measurement circuitry, but electrically isolated therefrom.
 10. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, and further comprising a wireless communication module coupled to the signal processing circuitry and configured to generate a wireless signal based on information received from the signal processing circuitry.
 11. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 10, wherein the wireless communication module is configured to receive wireless communication signals and provide information to the signal processing circuitry based on the received wireless communication signals.
 12. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, wherein the measurement circuitry is configured to couple to a plurality of process variable sensors and generate digital information relative to each process variable sensor.
 13. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 1, and further comprising second measurement circuitry operably coupled to at least one process variable sensor and to the first measurement circuitry.
 14. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 13, wherein at least one of the first and second measurement circuitry is coupled to a pressure sensor.
 15. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 14, wherein the pressure sensor is a capacitive pressure sensor.
 16. The electronic steam trap monitor of claim 14, wherein at least one of the first and second measurement circuitry includes a capacitance-to-digital converter. 